
Local players ask for enforcement of local content provisions in minerals sector
There is a general outcry among local players over foreigners dominating lucrative contracts in Malawi’s minerals sector, which has raised concerns over government’s failure to enforce local content provisions contained in the Mines and Minerals Act 2023 currently governing the sector.
The Act under Section 159 (3) reads: “ A holder of a mining licence required to have an approved goods and services procurement plan shall give preference to procuring goods and services from supplier and contractor entities owned by Malawian citizens, including equal opportunities to entities owned by Malawian women, provided such supplier and contractor entities offer terms as to prices, quantities, qualities and delivery schedules that are at least comparable to terms offered by non-Malawian contractors and suppliers to the maximum extent practicable consistent with efficient operations.”
But Mining & Trade Review continue to receive reports of locals being denied lucrative business and job opportunities with big mining companies preferring competitors from foreign countries mainly Zimbabwe, Zambia and South Africa.
The huge contract in a mining project is that of a mining contractor but Malawi’s operating big mines namely Kayelekera Uranium Mine in Karonga and Kangankunde Rare Earth Mine in Balaka opted for owner mining shutting out the possibility of hiring mining contractors.
A local construction firm, which roped in an experienced South African mining contractor to try its luck in the project, told Mining & Trade Review that it was a blow to learn that both Kayelekera and Kangankunde had opted for owner mining.
“Why is government entertaining this monopoly by foreign mining companies when the Act promotes local content? In many countries that have thriving mining sectors, locals are at the forefront in the sector as major suppliers and contractors,” questioned the contractor (name withheld).
The local construction executive also questioned why the mining companies are awarding simple jobs such as construction of access roads to gravel standards to foreign mining contractors.
Head of Sales and Marketing at Kabula Industrial Safety Specialists (KISS) Nancy Kapelemera Gondwe said just like contractors, local Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) suppliers are struggling to secure contracts in the minerals sector despite having the capacity to supply equipment required by mining companies.
Local suppliers incluidng KISS supplies various safety equipment, including helmets, gloves, safety boots, earmuffs, safety suits and protective glasses.
However, Gondwe expressed concern that mining companies appear to favour foreign suppliers, leaving local businesses with limited opportunities to participate in the mining supply chain.
"We have all the PPEs required in the mining sector, but honestly, we are not awarded contracts to supply them.," she said.
MD for Lilongwe based Drill Max Remi Kagwa echoed Gondwe’s sentiments in a seperate interview saying despite local companies stocking drilling equipment similar to those that foreign drilling contractors are using, it is difficult for the locals to secure contracts.
“I think government needs to introduce regulations to ensure that the foreign contractors partner locals,” he said.
Mining sector consultant Ignatius Kamwanje in a separative interview also called for stronger partnerships between local and foreign companies to ensure increased participation of locals in lucrative contracts in the sector.
"There is a need for joint ventures when an international company is engaged, it is necessary to incorporate local consultants," he said.
Natural Resources Justice Network (NRJN) programmes officer Joy Chabwera said Malawi established important legal mechanisms for promoting local participation, but implementation remains a major challenge.
Chabwera argued that although the Mines and Minerals Act, 2023, provides a framework for local participation, challenges remain in translating its provisions into meaningful economic benefits, particularly in ownership, employment, procurement, skills development and mineral processing.
He said the absence of sufficiently detailed local-content regulations, alongside weaknesses in enforcement and community preparedness is limiting the benefits citizens should obtain from the sector.
“As far as we know, there is no detailed local-content regulations with clear targets for jobs, procurement and skills transfer,” he said.
Chabwera said communities and district councils also need greater technical capacity and access to relevant agreements to enable them to negotiate, monitor and assess the benefits arising from mining activities.
He called for measurable local-content requirements, public disclosure of community development agreements and corporate social responsibility plans, as well as adequate funding for district councils to monitor mining-related commitments.
Chabwera said large and medium-scale mining licence holders should be required to submit annual local-content plans and reports showing how they are involving Malawian businesses and workers.
He said the coming Act should include local content thresholds for mining companies to meet.
Chabwera also said the Act should include specific business opportunities to be reserved for locally owned companies in areas such as catering, transport, security, construction, equipment hire and maintenance.
Chabwera said contracts should be divided into manageable packages to enable small businesses to compete for opportunities that might otherwise be beyond their capacity.
To improve transparency, he proposed establishing a public register of local suppliers and requiring mining companies to advertise procurement opportunities openly.
He said the Mining and Minerals Regulatory Authority (MMRA) should verify the ownership of businesses claiming to be local to prevent foreign-owned companies from disguising themselves as Malawian enterprises to access local-content opportunities.
Chabwera said it is important for mining companies' local-participation commitments, community development agreements and corporate social responsibility plans to be made public and monitored.
Federation of Artisanal and Small-Scale Mining in Malawi (FASMIM) President Percy Maleta said the country needs to move beyond treating Malawians primarily as workers in the mining industry and create opportunities for them to become investors, owners, processors and competitive mining entrepreneurs.
Maleta said access to finance and technology, skills development and deliberate support for local mineral processing are essential if Malawians are to capture a greater share of the value generated from their country's mineral resources.
“Malawians must move beyond participating as labourers to becoming owners, investors, processors and competitive mining businesses,” he said.
Maleta said the effectiveness of the legal framework should be assessed by examining how much ownership, wealth and business opportunities remain in the hands of Malawians.
Seasoned Gemologist Yamikani Jimusole in a separate interview questioned whether the country is making sufficient progress in ensuring citizens benefited from mineral ownership.
He observed that in mining projects such as Chimwadzulu Corundum in Ntcheu and Kayelekera, Malawians have not benefited sufficiently as shareholders or participants in the higher-value aspects of mining.
While acknowledging that mining generates employment and government revenue, he said these benefits do not necessarily translate into ownership of mining companies or meaningful participation in the value chain by locals.
Jimusole said the government continues securing an ownership interest in mining projects while ordinary citizens will remain excluded unless mechanisms are introduced to support citzens’ participation.
He argued that financing arrangements and opportunities to participate from the exploration stage would help Malawians secure a stake in projects before their value increases substantially.
Mining engineer Denis Mkandawire said it is difficult to determine whether Malawi is succeeding in terms of local participation in the sector because comprehensive and transparent information about local participation is not readily available.
He said the effectiveness of the law should be measured through evidence showing how much revenue district councils receive, whether communities benefit from development agreements, and how many jobs and contracts go to Malawians.
Mkandawire also raised concern about weaknesses in coordination by government agencies to ensure utilisation of locally available resources, citing the importation of coal from Tanzania by a cement company despite Malawi having its own coal reserves.
He said monitoring and enforcement of local content provisions in the Act should extend beyond administrative offices to the actual mining sites and communities.
Mkandawire also said the government needs to make information publicly available on the ownership of mining businesses, the employment of local professionals, the awarding of contracts and the distribution of mining revenues.
“Without such information, it will remain difficult to establish whether the country's mineral resources are generating sufficient benefits for its citizens,” he said.
Minister of Mining Honourable Thoko Tembo has been championing local particpation in the mineral sector including encouraging foreign owned mining companies operating in Malawi to list on Malawi Stock Exchange.